Date
Wed Nov 18A composite cedar shake roof is a planning choice, not a product name you can order from one catalog. Homeowners around Redmond, Bellevue, Kirkland, and the rest of the Puget Sound usually start because they want the split-wood look of cedar without committing to natural wood. The useful next step is a side-by-side plan: the look you want, the roof you already have, and the questions an installer has to answer before anyone tears off the old covering.
Call Landmark Roofing & Siding at (855) 908-7663 to schedule a cedar-look roof consult before you lock a material.
What should a composite cedar shake roof match on your house?
Start with the roof people already see, not with a sample chip. On many Eastside and Seattle-area homes the roof is the main design feature: steep planes, deep eaves, dormers, and valleys that catch shade and moss. A manufactured cedar look has to hold up at that scale. A small sample can look rustic in a showroom and look flat once it covers a 2,000-square-foot roof.
Landmark’s cedar shake roofing work uses two natural profiles as the reference point. Hand-split shakes have a textured face and a sawn back. Tapersawn shakes are sawn on both sides for a smoother, more even surface. Both come in a range of thicknesses, grades, and lengths. A composite cedar shake roof should be judged against that same split: do you want the rough, irregular shadow of hand-split cedar, or the cleaner lines of tapersawn?
Ask to see full-size pieces in daylight and in shade. Color names such as weathered gray or mossy cedar do not tell you how the surface reads after a wet week. If the house already has cedar siding or stained trim, bring a photo of that elevation. Choose the roof color against the rest of the exterior, not against a brochure background.
How does composite cedar compare with natural cedar?
Natural cedar and a manufactured cedar look solve different problems. Cedar is the real wood surface Landmark has installed across Puget Sound for more than 15 years, with hand-split and tapersawn options sized to the house. A composite cedar shake roof uses a manufactured covering molded to suggest that wood texture. The two are not interchangeable, and a claim about one product’s fire assembly, warranty, or upkeep does not transfer to the other.
Use the comparison below as a planning sheet, not as a scorecard. Confirm every line against the current instructions for the exact profile in the proposal.
| Planning question | Natural cedar shake | Composite cedar shake roof |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Hand-split texture or a smoother tapersawn face. | Molded cedar-style texture. Depth varies by product. |
| Wet-climate care | Plan for moss, moisture, and finish. | Not maintenance-free. Follow that product’s care guide. |
| What to read first | Grade, thickness, length, and roof shape. | Current install guide, warranty, and any test report. |
| Who installs it | A crew experienced with cedar in Puget Sound. | A crew trained to that maker’s fastening and accessories. |
If the goal is a wood roof and you are ready for wood care, stay with cedar. If the goal is the cedar look and you want the covering specified as a manufactured system, keep the conversation on the composite product’s own documents. For a wider look at how rain, shade, and moss shape material choice in this climate, read Landmark’s guide to the best roof for a rainy Washington climate.
Which install details should you discuss before choosing?
The material decision fails when the roof geometry is an afterthought. Walk the house, or the photos from the attic and the eaves, and write down slope, layers already on the deck, and every place water changes direction. Valleys, chimneys, skylights, and sidewall intersections are where a cedar-look roof is won or lost.
Bring these questions to the consult:
- Does the chosen profile allow your roof slope, including the lowest plane?
- What deck and underlayment does the current instruction require, and is tear-off included?
- Which flashing, hip, ridge, and starter pieces are in the written scope, not just in a photo?
- How are fasteners, exposure, and spacing specified for this product, and who on the crew is trained to that method?
- What does the warranty actually cover, and what maintenance keeps it in force?
Landmark installs with its own crews and manages the job in house, from the first look through warranty. That matters on a composite cedar shake roof because the manufacturer’s method is the method. A crew that guesses at exposure or swaps an accessory can void the coverage you thought you bought. If you want the full sequence for a wood shake project as a contrast, Landmark’s cedar shake roof installation guide shows how a natural cedar job is staged. Do not treat those wood steps as the steps for a manufactured product.
One public evaluation shows why the paperwork matters. It is not a promise about every brand. QAI Laboratories revised report CERu-1014 in April 2025. It covers Brava cedar shake and related composite tiles. The report describes polymeric coverings that can reach Class A or Class C when installed as specified. The tested slopes start at 3:12. That rating belongs to the tested assembly. Ask whether your product has a current report. Ask whether your roof will be built to that assembly. A sample board has no fire classification. Read the report at QAI’s Brava code evaluation (CERu-1014, revised April 2025).
How do Puget Sound roofs change the plan?
Redmond’s tree cover, Bellevue and Kirkland’s shaded lots, and wet weeks from Seattle through Issaquah all push debris into valleys and onto the north side of a roof. Landmark’s cedar page is direct about this: cedar is durable, and selecting the right material still matters in a wet Northwest climate. The same climate test applies to a manufactured cedar look. Moss on a composite surface is a cleaning question. Moss under a poorly detailed valley is a leak question.
Landmark Roofing & Siding is family-owned and has been based in Redmond since 2005. The shop is at 14940 NE 95th Street, Suite H. These roofs are planned as local exterior work. They are not a material ordered from a national catalog and left at the curb. Projects run across the Puget Sound communities the company serves, including Sammamish, Woodinville, Bothell, Renton, and Tacoma. Crews also coordinate siding, windows, and gutters when the roof job exposes rotten trim or tired gutters. That is often the right time to fix the edge details a new cedar-look field will drain into.
Budget talk should stay tied to your roof, not to a national average. Landmark publishes an instant roofing cost calculator that uses the address to estimate area, pitch, and complexity. Use it to frame the conversation. A steep, cut-up roof with several dormers will not price like a simple gable, whether the covering is cedar or composite. For payment timing, ask about current financing options at the consult rather than assuming a rate from an old page. Landmark’s lifetime craftsmanship warranty applies to full roof replacements for the original homeowner and can transfer once within 20 years. Repairs and partial replacements are outside that warranty, so say clearly whether you want a full replacement.
What should the written proposal include?
A useful proposal names the system, not just the look. Ask for the manufacturer, the profile, and the color in writing. Ask for the tear-off plan, the deck repairs that are included, and the underlayment the instructions require. Flashing at chimneys, skylights, and sidewalls should be line items. So should hip and ridge pieces, starters, and any vents the new field will cover.
Landmark writes estimates and sends project updates so you can see the scope before the crew arrives. That habit matters on a composite cedar shake roof because accessory pieces are easy to leave off a verbal bid. If a valley kit or a specific fastener is required, it should appear in the scope. If the proposal says “cedar style” without a product name, send it back.
Warranty language needs the same treatment. Landmark’s lifetime craftsmanship warranty covers full roofing replacements for the original homeowner. It can transfer once to a later owner within 20 years of installation. It does not cover repairs, patchwork, or partial replacements. It also does not cover damage from a skipped maintenance plan or from another contractor altering the roof. The product warranty is separate. Read both before you compare a natural cedar bid with a manufactured one.
Payment and timing belong in the same conversation. Landmark’s published approach is a deposit to start and the balance at completion, with financing available for qualified projects, including promotional 0% offers and terms that can run as long as 240 months. Confirm the current offer at the consult. Do not treat an old advertisement as the rate on your contract. A steep roof in Issaquah or a cut-up roof in Bellevue will also take longer than a simple gable in a clear lot. Weather holds are normal from late fall through early spring.
How should you compare two bids?
Put both bids on one page. Check that each names the same tear-off, the same flashing locations, and a full replacement rather than a overlay. Then compare the material on its own documents. A lower number that skips hip pieces or deck repair is not a better composite cedar shake roof. It is a different job.
Use the roofing project gallery to see how finished Landmark roofs sit on real Puget Sound houses. Photos will not replace a site visit. They will show the difference between a textured field and a flat one before you pick a profile.
When should you request a consult?
Request the consult when you can answer three things. Name the look you want, either hand-split texture or a smoother tapersawn-style surface. Say whether you are comparing that look with real cedar or replacing cedar outright. Say whether the job is a full replacement. Bring photos of the street elevation, any known leaks, and the age of the current roof if you have it.
A consult is also the right time to separate this decision from a general composite overview. If you only need the category definition, Landmark already explains what a composite shake roof describes. This planning step is narrower: match a cedar look to this house, then decide whether natural cedar or a manufactured cedar-style covering belongs in the proposal.
Landmark is licensed, bonded, and insured, and the crews carry manufacturer certifications so the product you pick can be installed to that maker’s standard. You will get a written scope, not a verbal match to a photo. If the documents do not name the profile, the underlayment, and the flashing, the plan is not finished.
Request a consult through Landmark’s cedar shake roofing page, or call (855) 908-7663 to talk through a composite cedar shake roof on your home.
Frequently asked questions
Is a composite cedar shake roof the same as cedar?
No. Cedar shakes are wood, in hand-split or tapersawn profiles. A composite cedar shake roof is a manufactured covering shaped to suggest that look. Installation rules, warranties, and care follow the specific product, not the cedar trade.
Will composite cedar look like hand-split cedar?
Only if the profile you choose has real depth and irregular texture. Ask for full-size pieces and compare them with a hand-split shake, not with a website photo. A smoother product will read closer to tapersawn cedar.
Does a Class A rating apply to every composite cedar product?
No. A Class A or Class C result belongs to the assembly that was tested, installed as the evaluation report describes. Ask for the current report on the exact profile in your proposal. Do not assume another brand’s rating carries over.
Can Landmark install both cedar and a cedar-look composite?
Yes. Landmark installs natural cedar shake and also carries manufacturer certifications for composite roofing lines used on Puget Sound homes. The consult should name which system is in the scope before work starts.
How do I start if I am still comparing materials?
Call (855) 908-7663 or use the cedar shake roofing page to request a consult. Bring the look you want and any photos of the roof. The team can tell you whether natural cedar or a manufactured cedar-style system fits the house.
